A “cash for keys” agreement is a voluntary arrangement in which a landlord offers a tenant a financial incentive to vacate a rental unit. This alternative can help avoid the time, expense, and uncertainty of formal eviction proceedings. This article outlines what cash for keys agreements involve, their benefits, legal considerations under Ontario law, and how to implement them properly.
Key Takeaways
- Cash for keys agreements allow landlords and tenants to mutually agree to end a tenancy in exchange for financial compensation.
- Under Ontario’s Residential Tenancies Act (RTA), a landlord must not pressure, coerce, threaten, or mislead a tenant into such an agreement. Doing so may amount to harassment or unlawful interference with the tenant’s rights.
- Mutual consent and a clear written agreement—preferably using the Landlord and Tenant Board’s Form N11—are essential to ensure enforceability.
- Open communication and fair negotiations help ensure successful outcomes and reduce the likelihood of disputes.
What Is a Cash for Keys Agreement?
In Ontario, a cash for keys agreement refers to a voluntary arrangement where the tenant agrees to move out of a rental property in exchange for financial compensation from the landlord. These agreements are typically used to avoid formal eviction proceedings, which can be time-consuming and costly.
Tenants benefit by avoiding an eviction record and receiving assistance with relocation, while landlords regain possession of their property sooner and avoid legal expenses. Importantly, tenants have no obligation to accept a cash for keys offer and may choose to remain in the unit.
Get a Free Quote for Your Real Estate Transaction
Insight Law Professional Corporation is a real estate law firm located in Toronto. If you need legal assistance with your real estate transaction, contact us today to learn how we can help.
Legal Considerations Under Ontario Law
Cash for keys agreements are legal in Ontario if they are made voluntarily and without coercion. Landlords must adhere strictly to the Residential Tenancies Act, 2006, which governs all residential rental agreements in the province.
Key legal points:
- Voluntary Consent: Any agreement to terminate a tenancy must be made voluntarily. A tenant has the right to refuse without consequence.
- No Coercion or Harassment: Section 22 of the RTA prohibits landlords from harassing, threatening, coercing, or misleading tenants to induce them to vacate.
- Proper Documentation: It is strongly recommended that parties use Form N11 – Agreement to End the Tenancy, available from the Landlord and Tenant Board, to formalize the agreement.
- Legal Advice: Tenants are encouraged to seek independent legal advice. Landlords should also consider consulting legal counsel to ensure compliance and proper documentation.
When to Consider a Cash for Keys Agreement
Scenarios where a landlord might consider offering a cash for keys agreement include:
- The landlord or an immediate family member intends to move into the rental unit (in which case a proper N12 notice must also be issued if no agreement is reached).
- The property is being sold and vacant possession is required by the purchaser.
- The landlord is planning significant renovations requiring vacant possession (subject to N13 requirements).
- The tenant is behind on rent, and both parties prefer to avoid eviction proceedings.
- There is an ongoing conflict or deteriorating landlord-tenant relationship that both parties wish to end amicably.
Note: A cash for keys agreement must not be used to circumvent notice periods or compensation obligations required by the RTA.
Steps to Implement a Cash for Keys Agreement
1. Open and Transparent Communication
Landlords should approach the tenant respectfully and explain the purpose of the offer. The conversation should be framed as a voluntary proposal, not a demand or ultimatum. Clarify that the tenant is under no obligation to accept the offer.
2. Negotiating Fair Compensation
Offer a reasonable amount based on:
- The tenant’s length of tenancy.
- Current rental market conditions.
- The cost and difficulty of finding new accommodation.
- Whether the tenant has special circumstances (e.g., disability, low income).
Negotiation strategies may include:
- Offering moving assistance.
- Providing extended time to vacate.
- Increasing the offer based on the tenant’s needs.
3. Use a Properly Drafted Written Agreement
The agreement should:
- Clearly state that the tenant is vacating voluntarily.
- Set out the amount of money being paid.
- Specify the move-out date.
- Be signed and dated by both parties.
Using the Form N11 is the preferred method in Ontario. Keep a copy of the agreement and proof of payment in case of future disputes.
Benefits for Landlords
- Avoids legal fees and time associated with eviction proceedings.
- Provides a predictable timeline for regaining possession.
- Helps maintain a cooperative relationship with tenants.
- Reduces risk of damage or conflict during the vacating process.
Benefits for Tenants
- Provides financial support for relocation costs.
- Avoids the stigma and potential credit impact of an eviction.
- Allows for a dignified and negotiated departure.
- May include assistance or flexible timelines.
Potential Challenges and Mitigation Strategies
| Challenge | Suggested Approach |
|---|---|
| Tenant refuses or demands more | Reassess the offer based on tenancy history, market conditions, and urgency. Emphasize that the agreement is voluntary under the RTA, and the tenant has no obligation to accept. If negotiations fail, consider lawful alternatives such as issuing a Form N12 or N13, if appropriate. |
| Tenant does not vacate on time | Ensure the agreement includes a clear move-out date and is properly documented (preferably using Form N11). If the tenant remains in possession after the agreed date, seek legal advice and consider filing with the Landlord and Tenant Board for enforcement. |
| Disagreement over terms | Document all negotiations in writing using clear, neutral language. Utilize Form N11 to avoid ambiguity. Engage in open communication and, if necessary, consider mediation or seek a lawyer. |
Key Considerations Before Finalizing
- Confirm that the agreement is truly voluntary.
- Use Form N11 where possible.
- Retain documentation of the agreement and payment.
- Respect all rights under the RTA.
- Seek legal advice to avoid unintended consequences.
Summary
Cash for keys agreements offer a lawful, practical, and often cost-effective way for landlords and tenants to end a tenancy voluntarily. When conducted properly and respectfully, these agreements can protect both parties’ interests, maintain dignity, and avoid the risks and delays of formal eviction proceedings.
However, Ontario landlords must ensure that such arrangements comply with the Residential Tenancies Act. A written agreement, fair compensation, and legal transparency are essential to safeguarding both parties’ rights and reaching a successful outcome.
The information provided above is of a general nature and should not be considered legal advice. Every transaction or circumstance is unique, and obtaining specific legal advice is necessary to address your particular requirements. Therefore, if you have any legal questions, it is recommended that you consult with a lawyer.
